Page Nav

SHOW

Ads Place

A Beat Sent by Text Message Is Now a Federal Case: Ye and Ty Dolla $ign Sued Over "Vultures"


 

Every producer in the business has sent a beat by text message. Two of them now say that is exactly how their work ended up on one of the biggest rap albums of the decade — no contract, no license, no check. On Friday, November 6, producers Jaraed "Jae" Deal and Marlon "Marlonwiththeglasses" Barrow filed a 24-page copyright complaint in federal court in California against Ye, Ty Dolla $ign, Yeezy Record Label LLC, Yeezy LLC and Create Music Group.

The song at the center of it is "Vultures," the lead single and title track of Ye and Ty Dolla $ign's Vultures 1, which topped the Billboard 200 in February 2024. Deal and Barrow say the record is built on "Joint 2," a composition they created together in November 2018 and own in equal shares — written, like so many beats are, to shop to recording artists.

The complaint tells a story about friendship as much as business. Barrow is a longtime friend and collaborator of Ty Dolla $ign. During a phone call, Ty allegedly heard "Joint 2" playing, liked what he heard and asked about it. Barrow sent the MP3 by text — as a preview, the suit says, with the understanding that the high-quality files and the stems would follow once a written agreement was in place. That agreement, the producers say, never came. Instead, Ty passed the music along to Ye, and versions of "Vultures" began reaching commercial platforms in November 2023.

What happened after the release splits the two plaintiffs. Barrow was given a producer credit on the song — and, he says, not one dollar in compensation. Deal says he received neither credit nor payment. The pair say they raised the issue inside the Yeezy camp, including with producer 88-Keys, identified in the filing as Yeezy's head of music, and that a buyout offer from Yeezy's legal team in October 2024 failed to settle it.

The filing reaches beyond the album cut. It covers the multiple versions of "Vultures" in circulation — the single, the Vultures Pack EP and the album version — along with the separate stem files of "Joint 2" itself, and it points to a copyright registration for the underlying composition dated July 9, 2025. In other words, the producers are not arguing over a loop buried in the mix. They are claiming the foundation of the record, in every form it was sold.

The producers' lawyers frame the case around "the essential right of any artist to determine when, how, and by whom their creative work is used." The suit seeks damages and profits, a jury trial, and court orders restricting further use of the work — pointing to a Vultures merchandise operation the complaint describes as grossing more than $100 million.

Neither Ye nor Ty Dolla $ign has publicly responded. The case joins a crowded docket of clearance fights trailing Ye's recent run — including a separate producer suit filed in August over Vultures 2 and Bully — and it lands on the oldest fault line in hip-hop: the sample. This time, though, there is no dusty vinyl and no forgotten session player. There are two producers, a phone call, and a text message that may end up deciding what a handshake is worth in the streaming era.

SOURCE: HOTNEWHIPHOP

No comments

Latest Articles